Systematic Review of Diversity and Curriculum Improvement Case Studies

Lessons for Inclusion and Research Instruction in Library and Information Science Programs


  • Sarah Ryan University of North Texas
  • Mohotarema Rashid



diversity, university curriculum, programmatic self-study, research methods pedagogy, systematic reviewing


How should Library and Information Science (LIS) programs assess and refine their diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) instruction? We should leverage the work of health science departments. In a systematic review of DEI curriculum advancement studies published from 2010-2022, we located 46 studies concentrated in the health sciences (n=20). We found five article characteristic trends in: (1) year of publication, (2) discipline, (3) study location, (4) research methods, and (5) highly-included identity topics. We found five prevalent approaches to curricular improvement: (1) an early all-student intervention, (2) a focus on cultural humility as the outcome, (3) attention to classroom climate and safety, (4) multi-year data analysis, and (5) a working group as leader of curricular change. Throughout our project, we noted three challenges to conducting systematic reviews: (1) the U.S. bias of selected library databases, (2) missed studies due to database indexing and other issues, and (3) student coding issues. Our research suggests that dozens of strategies exist for measuring existing curricular content, that curricular change requires significant investment, and that LIS should transition to cultural humility as the focal outcome of diversity instruction.


ALISE (Association for Library and Information Science Education) (2013). ALISE diversity statement.

Altman, D. G. (1999). What randomized trials and systematic reviews can offer decision makers. Hormone Research in Paediatrics, 51(Suppl. 1), 36-43. DOI:

Arnett, M., & Forde, R. (2012). Increasing Student Diversity and Cultural Competence as Part of Loma Linda University School of Dentistry’s Service Mission. Journal of Dental Education, 76(6), 721–727. DOI:

Bero, L. A., & Jadad, A. R. (1997). How consumers and policymakers can use systematic reviews for decision making. Annals of Internal Medicine, 127(1), 37-42. DOI:

Boland, A., Cherry, M. G., & Dickson, R. (2017). Doing a systematic review: A student's guide (2nd ed.). Sage.

Bourgeois, T. (2018, January 10). The role of education in advancing a diversity and inclusion breakthrough: Linking education to the workforce of the future. HuffPost.

Braun, H. M., Ramirez, D., Zahner, G. J., Gillis-Buck, E. M., Sheriff, H., & Ferrone, M. (2017). The LGBTQI health forum: An innovative interprofessional initiative to support curriculum reform. Medical Education Online, 22(1), 1306419. DOI:

Brown, J. V., Spicer, K. J., & French, E. (2021). Exploring the inclusion of cultural competence, cultural humility, and diversity concepts as learning objectives or outcomes in healthcare curricula. Journal of Best Practices in Health Professions Diversity: Education, Research & Policy, 14(1), 63–81.

Chancellor, R.L., DeLoacha, P., Dunbar, A., Lee, S., & Singh, R. (2021). From protests to practice:

Confronting systemic racism in LIS. Education for Information, 37(2), 173-186.

Charania, N.A.M.A., & Patel, R. (2022). Diversity, equity, and inclusion in nursing education: Strategies and processes to support inclusive teaching. Journal of Professional Nursing, 42, 67-72. DOI:

Clarke, M., & Chalmers, I. (2018). Reflections on the history of systematic reviews. BMJ Evidence-Based Medicine, 23(4), 121-122. DOI:

Chun, M. B. (2010). Pitfalls to avoid when introducing a cultural competency training initiative. Medical Education, 44(6), 613-620. DOI:

Coats, L., & King, S. (2022). The presence of courses that address diversity in community college curricula. Community College Journal of Research and Practice, 46(7), 504–510. DOI:

Cole, E. R., Case, K. A., Rios, D., & Curtin, N. (2011). Understanding what students bring to the classroom: Moderators of the effects of diversity courses on student attitudes. Cultural Diversity & Ethnic Minority Psychology, 17(4), 397–405. DOI:

Colón-Aguirre, M., & Cooke, N. (2022, October). Critical race theory in library and information DOI:

science (LIS) education. In Proceedings of the ALISE Annual Conference.

Conte, M. L., MacEachern, M. P., Mani, N. S., Townsend, W. A., Smith, J. E., Masters, C., & Kelley, C. (2015). Flipping the classroom to teach systematic reviews: The development of a continuing education course for librarians. Journal of the Medical Library Association, 103(2), 69-73. DOI:

Cook, D. A., & West, C. P. (2012). Conducting systematic reviews in medical education: A stepwise approach. Medical Education, 46(10), 943-952. DOI:

Cooke, N. A. (2013a). Diversifying the LIS faculty. Library Journal, 138(15).

Cooke, N. A. (2013b). It takes a village: The value of multiple instructor voices in the online classroom. In A. Sigal (Ed.), Advancing library education: Technological innovation and instructional design (pp. 141-152). IGI Global. DOI:

Cooke, N.A. (2016). Counter-storytelling in the LIS curriculum. In U. Gorham, N. Greene DOI:

Taylor, & P.T. Jaeger (Eds.), Perspectives on libraries as institutions of human rights and social justice (pp. 331-348). Emerald Group Publishing.

Cooke, N.A. (2018). Creating mirrors and doors in the curriculum: Diversifying and re- DOI:

envisioning the MLS. In J. Percell, L.C. Sarin, & P.T. Jaeger (Eds.), Re-Envisioning the

MLS, Part B: Perspectives of the Future of Library Science Education (pp. 27-48).

Emerald Group Publishing.

Cushman, L. F., Delva, M., Franks, C. L., Jimenez-Bautista, A., Moon-Howard, J., Glover, J., & Begg, M. D. (2015). Cultural competency training for public health students: Integrating self, social, and global awareness into a master of public health curriculum. American Journal of Public Health, 105(S1), S132-S140. DOI:

Cuyler, A. C. (2017). A survey of arts management educators’ teaching on diversity issues. The Journal of Arts Management, Law, and Society, 47(3), 192-202. DOI:

Daya, S., Illangasekare, T., Tahir, P., Bochatay, N., Essakow, J., Ju, M., & van Schaik, S. (2022). Using simulation to teach learners in health care behavioral skills related to diversity, equity, and inclusion: A scoping review. Simulation in Healthcare, 10.1097/SIH.0000000000000690. DOI:

Denson, N., Bowman, N., Ovenden, G., Culver, K., & Holmes, J. (2021). Do diversity courses improve college student outcomes? A meta-analysis. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education, 14(4), 544–556. DOI:

Dunbar, A., Zamir, H., Chancellor, R., Grady, S. D., Gray, L., & Kumasi, K. (2022, October).

Critical race theory as innovative pedagogy in LIS: SIG: Innovative Pedagogy. In Proceedings of the ALISE Annual Conference.

Fougner, M., & Horntvedt, A. T. (2012). Perceptions of Norwegian physiotherapy students: Cultural diversity in practice. Physiotherapy Theory and Practice, 28(1), 18–25. DOI:

Franco, D. (2021). Revisiting cultural diversity in social work education through Latino Critical Race Theory testimonio. Social Work Education, 40(4), 522-534. DOI:

Garrido, R., Prado, M., & Chaparro, R. (2021). Diversity and equity in Ibero-American universities: An ecological analysis and proposals for action-research from psychology. Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology, 31(6), 796–810. DOI:

Gómez, J. M. (2022). Diversity wanted! Utilizing transdisciplinary scholarship on structural inequality to educate psychology graduate students. Teaching of Psychology, 0(0), 1-6.

Grant, C., & Allweiss, A. (2014). Tracing the arc: The shifting conceptualizations of educational “disadvantage” and “diversity” at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Social Inclusion, 2(1), 34–46. DOI:

Grant, M. J., & Booth, A. (2009). A typology of reviews: An analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies. Health Information and Libraries Journal, 26(2), 91–108. DOI:

Gustafson, D. L., & Reitmanova, S. (2010). How are we ‘doing’cultural diversity? A look across English Canadian undergraduate medical school programmes. Medical Teacher, 32(10), 816-823. DOI:

Hays, K., Barrera, A., Ogbadu-Oladapo, L., Oyedare, O., Payne, J., Rashid, M., Stanley, J., Stocker, L., Lueg, C., Twidale, M., & West, R. (2022). A state of the art and scoping review of embodied information behavior in shared, co-present extended reality experiences. Electronic Imaging, 34(12), 298-1-298–19. DOI:

Hunter, C. S., Adames, T. R., Franco, S., Hosgood, D., & Correa, N. (2019). Analysis of the curriculum of a summer pipeline program for economically disadvantaged premedical students in the Bronx, NY. Journal of Best Practices in Health Professions Diversity: Education, Research & Policy, 12(1), 1–23.

Jaeger, P. T., Subramaniam, M. M., Jones, C. B., & Bertot, J. C. (2011). Diversity and LIS

education: Inclusion and the age of information. Journal of Education for Library and Information Science, 166-183.

Kitchenham, B. (2004). Procedures for performing systematic reviews. Keele University. Available at:

Komba, M. M., & Lwoga, E. T. (2020). Systematic review as a research method in library and DOI:

information science. In P. Ngulube (Ed.), Handbook of Research on Connecting Research Methods for Information Science Research (pp. 80-94). IGI Global.

Kumasi, K.D. and Manlove, N.L. (2015). Finding ‘diversity levers’ in the core library and

information science curriculum: a social justice imperative.” Library Trends, 64(2), 415-443. DOI:

Laird, T. F. N. (2011). Measuring the diversity inclusivity of college courses. Research in Higher Education, 52(6), 572–588. DOI:

Land, S.C., & Booth, D. (2020). Systematic review and meta-analysis as a structured platform for teaching principles of experimentation. Advances in Physiology Education, 44(3), 276-285. DOI:

Lee, A., Williams, R., & Kilaberia, R. (2012). Engaging diversity in first-year college classrooms. Innovative Higher Education, 37, 199-213. DOI:

Lee, S. A., Chancellor, R., Chu, C. M., Rodriguez-Mori, H., & Roy, L. (2015). Igniting diversity:

Actionable methods and ideas for advancing diversity in LIS education in the US. Journal

of Education for Library and Information Science, 56(s1), 47-60.

Liberati, A., Altman, D. G., Tetzlaff, J., Mulrow, C., Gotzsche, P. C., Ioannidis, J. P. A., Clarke, M., Devereaux, P. J., Kleijnen, J., & Moher, D. (2009). The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: Explanation and elaboration. BMJ, 339(jul21 1), b2700–b2700. DOI:

Lindberg, B. M., Fulleborn, S. T., Semelrath, K. M., Lee, R. C., & Nguyen, D. R. (2019). Steps to improving sexual and gender diversity curricula in undergraduate medical education. Military Medicine, 184(1–2), e190–e194. DOI:

Ludwig, S., Dettmer, S., Wurl, W., Seeland, U., Maaz, A., & Peters, H. (2020). Evaluation of curricular relevance and actual integration of sex/gender and cultural competencies by final year medical students: Effects of student diversity subgroups and curriculum. Gms Journal For Medical Education, 37(2).

Maestro, R. S., Ramos-Eclevia, M., Eclevia, C. L., & Fredeluces, J. C. L. T. (2018). Teaching diversity, becoming inclusive: Perspectives and possibilities in ASEAN library and information science schools. Journal of the Australian Library and Information Association, 67(2), 96–115. DOI:

Mahmić-Kaknjo, M., Tomić, V., Ellen, M.E. et al. (2023). Delphi survey on the most promising areas and methods to improve systematic reviews’ production and updating. Systematic Reviews 12, 56. DOI:

Mehra, B., Hope, O.A., & Ahmad, S. (2011). Integrating diversity across the LIS curriculum:

An exploratory study of instructors’ perceptions and practices online. IFLA Journal,

(1), 39-51.

Mengist, W., Soromessa, T., & Legese, G. (2020). Method for conducting systematic literature review and meta-analysis for environmental science research. MethodsX, 7, 100777. DOI:

Miller, K., & Alves, E. (2022). The state of diversity in criminal justice higher education: An analysis of curricula in criminal justice bachelor’s degree programs. Journal of Criminal Justice Education. DOI:

Mulliken, A. (2016). Technology, diversity, web accessibility, and ALA accreditation standards in MLIS. The International Journal of Information, Diversity, & Inclusion, 1, 1–19. DOI:

Muntinga, M., Krajenbrink, V., Peerdeman, S., Croiset, G., & Verdonk, P. (2016). Toward diversity-responsive medical education: Taking an intersectionality-based approach to a curriculum evaluation. Advances In Health Sciences Education, 21(3), 541–559. DOI:

Narayanasamy, A., Jurgens, F., Narayanasamy, M., & Guo, P. (2013). Diversity project: Mapping of diversity teaching and learning in nurse education curriculum. Journal of Further and Higher Education, 37(4), 536–551. DOI:

Nazar, M., Kendall, K., Day, L., & Nazar, H. (2015). Decolonising medical curricula through diversity education: lessons from students. Medical Teacher, 37(4), 385-393. DOI:

Ndumu, A., & Betts-Green, C. (2018). First Impressions. The International Journal of Information, Diversity, & Inclusion, 2(3), 91–113. DOI:

Nind, M. (2020). Teaching systematic review. Systematic Reviews in Educational Research, 55–68. DOI:

Otten, R., Faughnan, M., Flattley, M., & Fleurinor, S. (2022). Integrating equity, diversity, and inclusion into social innovation education: A case study of critical service-learning. Social Enterprise Journal, 18(1), 182–200. DOI:

Page, M.J., McKenzie, J.E., Bossuyt, P.M., Boutron, I., Hoffmann, T.C., Mulrow, C.D., et al. (2021). The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ, 372(71). DOI:

Pilic, A., Reda, S., Jo, C. L., Burchett, H., Bastías, M., Campbell, P., ... & Harder, T. (2023). Use of existing systematic reviews for the development of evidence-based vaccination recommendations: Guidance from the SYSVAC expert panel. Vaccine, 41(12), 1968-1978. DOI:

Pitt, R. N., & Packard, J. (2012). Activating diversity: The impact of student race on contributions to course discussions. The Sociological Quarterly, 53(2), 295–320. DOI:

Poole, A. H., Agosto, D., Greenberg, J., Lin, X., & Yan, E. (2021). Where do we stand? Diversity,

equity, inclusion, and social justice in North American library and information science education. Journal of Education for Library and Information Science, 62(3), 258-286. DOI:

Poole, A. H. (2021). Promoting diversity, equity, and inclusion in library and information science DOI:

through community-based learning. In Diversity, Divergence, Dialogue: 16th International Conference, iConference 2021, Beijing, China, March 17–31, 2021, Proceedings, Part I 16 (pp. 529-540). Springer International Publishing.

Prevatt, B.-S., Perkins, H., & Nance, A. (2021). Psychology today: A project to increase diversity in Psychology curriculum. Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in Psychology, 7(4), 288–300. DOI:

Roehrich, H., Grabanski, J., & Miceli, N. (2021). A study of an undergraduate marketing degree program: Opportunities for collaborative, inviting, and inclusive higher education practices. In Marketing Management Association Fall 2021 Educators’ Conference Proceedings.

Ryan, S. (2012). Assessing diversity in Public Affairs curricula: A multi-methodological model for student-led programmatic self-study. Journal of Public Affairs Education, 18(4), 757–774. DOI:

Sacchanand, C. (2015, August). Quality assurance of library and information science education in the ASEAN countries : Moving towards regionalization and internationalization. Paper presented at the IFLA World Library and Information Congress 20105, Cape Town, South Africa.

Sacchanand, C. (2016, August). Development of management strategies for collaboration in

information science education and research in the ASEAN Community. Paper presented at the IFLA World Library and Information Congress 2016 (pp. 1–11). Columbus, OH. http://library.

Sanner, S., Baldwin, D.E.E., Cannella, K.A., & Charles, J. (2010). The impact of cultural diversity forum on students’ openness to diversity. Journal of Cultural Diversity, 17(2), 56-61.

Schmidt, B. J., & MacWilliams, B. R. (2015). Evaluating an accelerated nursing program: A dashboard for diversity. Journal of Professional Nursing, 31(2), 82–88. DOI:

Subramaniam, M. M., & Jaeger, P. T. (2011). Weaving diversity into LIS: An examination of diversity course offerings in iSchool programs. Education for Information, 28(1), 1-19. DOI:

Subramaniam, M. M., & Jaeger, P. T. (2010). Modeling inclusive practice?: Attracting diverse

faculty and future faculty to the information workforce. Library Trends, 59(1), 109-127. DOI:

Temple University Libraries. Systematic reviews & other review types [Library Guide].

Tervalon, M., & Murray-Garcia, J. (1998). Cultural humility versus cultural competence: A critical distinction in defining physician training outcomes in multicultural education. Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Underserved, 9(2), 117-125. DOI:

Treichler, E. B., Crawford, J. N., Higdon, A., & Backhaus, A. L. (2020). Diversity and social

justice training at the postdoctoral level: A scoping study and pilot of a self-assessment. Training and Education in Professional Psychology, 14(2), 126. DOI:

Walker, L. F., & Hall, E. E. (2022) More than a tick box: An exploratory assessment of equity, diversity, and inclusion within an exercise science. Sport & Exercise Psychology Review, 40. DOI:

Williams-Reade, J. M., Lobo, E., & Gutierrez, G. (2019). Integrating spirituality into MFT training: A reflexive curriculum and qualitative evaluation. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 45(2), 219–232. DOI:

Winn, J. G., Miller, M. L., Muglia, C., Stewart, C., & Wallach, R. (2021). Situating LIS pedagogy and curriculum in diversity, equity, inclusion, accessibility, and anti-racism: A reflection on process. Reference Services Review, 50(1), 148–160. DOI:

Zanetti, M. L., Dinh, A., Hunter, L., Godkin, M. A., & Ferguson, W. (2014). A longitudinal study of multicultural curriculum in medical education. International Journal of Medical Education, 5, 37-44. DOI:

Zanting, A., Meershoek, A., Frambach, J. M., & Krumeich, A. (2020). The ‘exotic other’in medical curricula: Rethinking cultural diversity in course manuals. Medical Teacher, 42(7), 791-798. DOI:






Juried Papers